Our Drinks
Tally's $9 Drinks
PAMA Martini
Pama Pomegranate liqueur, Skyy pineapple, pomegranate syrup, lime juice and pineapple juice, shaken and served in a Martini glass
Raspberry Jolly Rancher
360 Raspberry and Peach vodka topped with cranberry juice and fresh lime, shaken and served over ice
Summer of 69
Crown Royal Peach, iced tea and lemonade, shaken and served over ice, garnished with a lemon wedge
Mango Punch
Captain Morgan, Malibu and fresh mango syrup, mixed with pineapple juice, fresh lime, splash of grenadine, shaken and served over ice
Spiked Mimosa
Champagne, spiked with cherry, mandarin, apple, cranberry, raspberry, pineapple, peach, watermelon, or mango vodka, topped with orange or pineapple juice and served over ice
Spiked Lemonade
Tito’s with your choice of fresh raspberry, strawberry, blueberry, mango, watermelon or pear syrup, topped with lemonade, shaken and served over ice
Tally's Bomb Pop
Absolut Citron, Smirnoff blue raspberry, lemonade, and grenadine served over ice
Banana Hammock
Malibu, cream de banana, Rumchata and pineapple juice shaken and served over ice
Blueberry Bourbon Smash
Fresh mint and lemon muddled with simple syrup and blueberry syrup, Bulliet Bourbon and club soda, shaken and served over ice
Mermaid Water
Captain Morgan, Malibu, splash of blue curacao, pineapple juice, fresh lime, shaken and served over ice
Chocolate Martini
Wheatly Vodka, Mozart Chocolate Liqueur, Bailey’s, chocolate syrup and cream, shaken and served in a Martini glass
Tequila - 30
Tequila-30 Happy Hour | $1.00 Off | Saturday’s 12pm - 5pm
Watermelon Margarita
$9.00
Don Julio Silver tequila, triple sec, fresh watermelon syrup and organic agave margarita mix, shaken and served over ice in a sugared pint glass
Patron Margarita
$9.00
Patron Silver and Citronge Orange mixed with our house
organic agave margarita mix, fresh lime juice, shaken and
served over ice in a salted pint glass
Jalapeño Margarita
$9.00
Espolon Reposado, triple sec, fresh lime and jalapeños
muddled, strained and shaken with orange juice and organic agave margarita mix, served over ice in a salted pint, garnished with jalapeño pepper and lime wedge
Golden Margarita
$9.00
Patron Silver, organic agave margarita mix, fresh lime, shaken and served over ice in a salted pint glass, topped with a float of Grand Marnier
Available
Cabo Wabo Blanco Silver | Don Julio Blanco | Espolon Reposado | Herradura Anejo | Hussong’s Silver, Reposado or Platinum | Jose Cuervo Gold | Maestro Dobel Diamante | Mandala Blanco, Reposado or Anejo | Patron Silver
Tally's Mules
Wisco Mule
$8.00
House vodka poured with Goslings Ginger Beer, and fresh lime, served over ice
Texas Mule
$8.00
Deep Eddy Peach, Cranberry, or Ruby Red Grapefruit Vodka, poured with Goslings Ginger Beer, and fresh lime, served over ice
Kentucky Mule
$8.00
Bulleit Bourbon or Bulleit 95 Rye Bourbon poured with
Goslings Ginger Beer, and fresh lime, served over ice | Add Rye +$1
Tangled up in Blue
$8.00
Western Son blueberry vodka and blueberry syrup poured with Goslings Ginger Beer and fresh lime juice, served over ice
Pear Mule
$8.00
Western Son prickly pear vodka, fresh pear syrup, fresh lime juice, poured with Goslings Ginger Beer, served over ice
Spiced Cranberry Mule
$8.00
Goodland Cranberry liquer poured with Goslings Ginger Beer and fresh lime juice, served over ice
Bloody Mary
Tally’s House Bloody Mary
$10.00
Absolut Vodka, rimmed with Forest Floor salt, Worcestershire sauce, fresh lemon and lime, pickled asparagus, dilly bean, mushroom, olive, spicy pickle, Klement’s beef sausage, Wisconsin cheese stick, served with Zing Zang bloody mary mix and your choice of tap beerchaser.
Upgrade
Effen Cucumber $1 | Hellfyre $1 | Johnny Walker Black $2 | Ketel One Citron $1 | Original Pickle Shot $1 | Referent Horseradish $1 | Tito’s $1
Tally’s Old-Fashioned
Old-Fashioned
$8.00
A cocktail made by muddling a cherry, orange slice, sugar and bitters, then adding alcohol, such as brandy, bourbon or whiskey. Traditionally served in a short, round, tumbler-like glass, which is called an Old Fashioned glass, named after the drink.
Available:
Brandy | Whiskey | Bourbon
Upgrade
Bulleit | Bulleit Rye | Crown Royal | Crown Royal Apple | Crown Royal Peach | Crown Royal Vanilla | Jack Daniels | Jim Beam | Jim Beam Red Stag | Korbel | Maker’s Mark | Maker’s 46 | Sazerac Rye | Southern Comfort
Tally's Mocktails
Junipre Mule
$6.00
Junipre non-alcoholic Botanical Spirit poured with Goslings Ginger Beer, and fresh lime, served over ice
Raspberry Margarita
$7.00
Raspberry purée, organic agave margarita mix, fresh lime and Sprite, shaken and served over ice in a salted pint glass
Sparkling Tropical Mocktail
$6.00
Pineapple juice and Mango syrup poured with Goslings Ginger Beer, and fresh lime, served over ice
Organic Paloma
$7.00
Tres Agave Organic Paloma mix and club soda, shaken and served over ice with a lime garnish in a salted clay jar
Classic Mojito
Your choice of alcohol, served with fresh mint and lime muddled with homemade simple syrup, club soda, shaken and served over ice
Available
Bacardi - Traditional, Strawberry or Raspberry | Captain Morgan Apple or Pineapple | Ketel One - Cucumber & Mint | Pama Pomegranate Liqueur | Western Son - Blueberry, Strawberry or Prickly Pear | 360 Vodka - Apple, Peach, Cherry, Mandarin, Mango or Watermelon
Bourbon
Angel’s Envy
Blanton’s
Buffalo Trace
Bulleit
EH Taylor JR Small Batch
Eagle Rare Small Batch 10YR
Elijah Craig Small Batch
High West
Jefferson’s Ocean
J. Henry Small Batch
Jim Beam
Maker’s Mark
Maker’s Mark 46
Old Elk Straight & Wheated
Rabbit Hole Dareringer Sherry Cask
Woodford Reserve & Double Oak
Whiskey
Angel's Envy Rye
Bulleit Rye
Elijah Craig Rye
Sazerac Rye 6YR
Tempelton Rye
Uncle Nearest 1856
Scotch/Irish Whiskey
Ardbeg 10YR
Jameson
Jameson Orange
Johnnie Walker Black & Red
Powers
Tullamore Dew
Bottled Beer
Coors Light
Miller Lite
Miller High Life
Miller 64
Budweiser
Bud Light
Pabst
Michelob Ultra
Redd's Apple Ale
Imports
Amstel Light
Hacker-Pschorr
Heineken
Corona
Corona Premier
Guinness
Modelo
Stella Artois
Seltzers
White Claw - Black Cherry
White Claw - Mango
White Claw - Raspberry
Hand Crafted Vodka Cocktails
Arizona Hard Iced Tea with Peach
Carbliss - Black Raspberry
Carbliss - Cranberry
Carbliss - Lemon-Lime
Carbliss - Peach
High Noon
Grapefruit
High Noon
Peach
High Noon
Watermelon
Tall Boys
Busch Light
Coors Light
Miller High Life
Pabst
Craft Cans
Kona - Big Wave Golden Ale
ABV 4.4%
Lakefront Brewery IPA
ABV 6.7%
Lakefront Brewery Riverwest Stein
ABV 6%
Third Space Happy Place
ABV 5.3%
Tiki Tom Slushie Series: Beermosa
ABV 5%
Wisconsin Brewing Co. Walk-Off Light Lager
ABV 4.2%