Skip to Main Content
Tally's Tap & Eatery logo topTally's Tap & Eatery logo scroll
  • (262)-446-3153
  • jtal3@yahoo.com
  • S31W24661 West Sunset Drive , Waukesha
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
    DRAFT LIST COCKTAIL & BOTTLED BEER
  • SPECIALS
  • EVENTS
  • CATERING
  • PARTIES
  • STORE
  • ORDER
  • JOBS
  • Twitter pageFacebook pageInstagram page
Tally's Tap & Eatery logo topTally's Tap & Eatery logo scroll
  • Twitter pageFacebook pageInstagram page
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • SPECIALS
  • EVENTS
  • CATERING
  • PARTIES
  • STORE
  • ORDER
  • JOBS
  • DRAFT LIST
  • COCKTAIL & BOTTLED BEER

Our Menu

MenuDaily Specials

Appetizers

Pork Carnitas Nachos photo

Pork Carnitas Nachos

$16.00
Pork carnita, provolone and monterey jack sauce, Pico de Gallo, over homemade tortilla chips, topped with guacamole and drizzed wih jalapaeno cilanto sauce
Teriyaki Lettuce Wraps photo

Teriyaki Lettuce Wraps

$13.00
Three lettuce leaves topped with sautéed chicken, bell peppers and onion in a teriyaki sesame glaze and sesame seeds
Potato Skins photo

Potato Skins

$14.00
Bacon, melted cheddar and green onion, served with sour cream
Dill Cheese Curds photo

Dill Cheese Curds

$11.00
White dill cheddar cheese in a light batter, served with ranch
Cheese Curds photo

Cheese Curds

$11.00
White cheddar cheese in a light batter, served with ranch or marinara
Korean Beef Tacos photo

Korean Beef Tacos

$14.00
Three flour tortillas filled with braised short rib, pickled cabbage, and carrot, topped with chipotle sour cream
Sweet Chili Shrimp photo

Sweet Chili Shrimp

$15.00
Beer battered shrimp tossed in sweet chili sauce, topped with green onion - Sub Mango Habanero Sauce
Portabella Mushrooms photo

Portabella Mushrooms

$12.00
Breaded portabella mushrooms served with marinara or ranch
Buffalo Chicken Dip photo

Buffalo Chicken Dip

$13.00
Choice of tortilla chips or celery & carrots
Spinach Artichoke Dip photo

Spinach Artichoke Dip

$13.00
Creamy spinach artichoke dip served with tortilla chips or celery & carrots
Beer Cheese Tally Fries photo

Beer Cheese Tally Fries

$13.00
With Bacon
Tortilla Chips with Guac photo

Tortilla Chips with Guac

$8.00
Fresh tortilla chips with homemade guac
Tortilla Chips with Pico de Gallo photo

Tortilla Chips with Pico de Gallo

$5.00
Fresh tortilla chips with homemade pico de gallo
Tortilla Chips with Salsa photo

Tortilla Chips with Salsa

$5.00
Fresh tortilla chips with salsa
Tortilla Chips with Cheese photo

Tortilla Chips with Cheese

$6.00
Fresh tortilla chips served with Monterey Jack cheese sauce
Butterfly Shrimp photo

Butterfly Shrimp

$7.50
Breaded butterfly shrimp, served with cocktail sauce and lemon. Minimum five per order. $1.50 per piece.
Mozzarella Sticks photo

Mozzarella Sticks

$10.00
Four hand wrapped won-ton, served with marinara sauce
Haystack Onion Rings photo

Haystack Onion Rings

$9.00
Crispy homemade haystack onion rings
Bacon Wrapped Jalapeño Poppers photo

Bacon Wrapped Jalapeño Poppers

$12.00
Hand wrapped jalapeno poppers stuffed with cream cheese and wrapped in bacon, served with ranch
Supreme Nachos photo

Supreme Nachos

$18.00
Tortilla chips piled with beef, tomato, green onion, black olive, and cheese, served with sour cream and salsa
1/2 Portion Nachos photo

1/2 Portion Nachos

$12.00
Half size - Tortilla chips piled with beef, tomato, green onion, black olive and cheese, served with sour cream and salsa

Nachos-Mods

$2.00/+
Verde Chicken $2 | Avocado $2 | Guac - $3 | Jalapeños - $1.50
Reuben Rolls photo

Reuben Rolls

$13.00
Four hand wrapped won-tons filled with corned beef, Swiss cheese and sauerkraut, served with thousand island
Quesadilla photo

Quesadilla

$13.00
Flour Tortilla stuffed with cheese and Pico de Gallo, served with chips, salsa and sour cream | Sub Verde Chicken or Pork Carnitas - $2 | Jalapeños - $1.50 | Avocado $2 | Guac - $3

Pretzels

Traditional Salted photo

Traditional Salted

$18.00
Served with beer cheese and honey mustard
Buffalo Chicken photo

Buffalo Chicken

$24.00
Homemade buffalo chicken dip stuffed into our giant pretzel, served with bleu cheese and ranch
Pizza photo

Pizza

$24.00
Pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage and cheese served with marinara and garlic butter
Spinach Artichoke photo

Spinach Artichoke

$24.00
Served with garlic butter and ranch

Pizza

Add Toppings: Each additional topping - 12" $2.00 | 16" $3.00

Supreme-12

Supreme-12"

$16.00
Cheese, sausage, mushroom and onion

Supreme-16"

$25.00
Cheese, sausage, mushroom and onion
Super Supreme-12

Super Supreme-12"

$17.00
Cheese, sausage, pepperoni, onion, green pepper, black olive and mushroom

Super Supreme-16"

$25.00
Cheese, sausage, pepperoni, onion, green pepper, black olive and mushroom
BBQ Chicken-12

BBQ Chicken-12"

$20.00
Memphis Sweet BBQ Sauce, grilled chicken, cheese, red onion, pineapple and cilantro

BBQ Chicken-16"

$27.00
Memphis Sweet BBQ Sauce, grilled chicken, cheese, red onion, pineapple and cilantro
Bruchetta Chicken Pizza-12

Bruchetta Chicken Pizza-12"

$20.00
Garlic, pizza sauce, fresh bruschetta, Portabella mushroom, fresh provolone, and parmesan, topped with a balsamic drizzle

Bruchetta Chicken Pizza-16"

$27.00
Garlic, pizza sauce, fresh bruschetta, Portabella mushroom, fresh provolone, and parmesan, topped with a balsamic drizzle
Cheese Pizza- 12

Cheese Pizza- 12"

$13.00
Served the way you like it! Topped with fresh provolone and all our fresh toppings!

Cheese Pizza- 16"

$18.00
Served the way you like it! Topped with fresh provolone and all our fresh toppings!
Crab Rangoon-12

Crab Rangoon-12"

$21.00
Buttery cream cheese sauce, cheese, crab and green onion, drizzled with sweet chili and topped with wonton strips

Crab Rangoon-16"

$28.00
Buttery cream cheese sauce, cheese, crab and green onion, drizzled with sweet chili and topped with wonton strips

Wings

Sauces: Tally's delicious wing sauces - Honey Roasted Garlic | Garlic Parmesan | Signature Sauce | Memphis Sweet BBQ | Teriyaki | Carolina Tangy | Jamaican Jerk | Sweet Chili | Sriracha Bourbon | Mild | Boom Boom | Sassy | Buffalo Ranch | Hot Honey | Mango Habanero | Hot | Dry Rub Ranch | Tally's Favorite | Cajun

Boneless Wings photo

Boneless Wings

$14.00
8 piece, 1 sauce | Lightly breaded, all-white meat boneless wings - Served with ranch or bleu cheese.

Boneless Wings

$25.00
16 piece, 2 sauces | Lightly breaded, all-white meat boneless wings - Served with ranch or bleu cheese

Boneless Wings

$36.00
24 piece, 2 sauces | Lightly breaded, all-white meat boneless wings - Served with ranch or bleu cheese
Traditional Wings photo

Traditional Wings

8 Jumbo crispy chicken wings with your choice of one sauce | MKT

Traditional wings

16 Jumbo crispy chicken wings with your choice of two sauces | MKT

Traditional Wings

24 Jumbo crispy chicken wings with your choice of three sauces | MKT

Salads

Dressings: French | Bleu Cheese | Ranch | Thousand Island | Honey Mustard | Avocado Poblano Ranch | Balsamic Vinaigrette

Tally's House Salad photo

Tally's House Salad

$6.00
Mixed greens, cheddar cheese, tomato, with homamde crutons and your choice of dressing
Cobb photo

Cobb

$18.00
Mixed greens topped grilled chicken, bacon, avocado, tomato, red onion, red pepper, hard-boiled egg, cheddar, and bleu cheese crumbles, served with garlic bread and your choice of dressing
Mama Tal's Chicken photo

Mama Tal's Chicken

$16.00
Mixed greens, grilled or crispy chicken, bacon, tomato, cheddar, avocado, served with garlic bread and your choice of honey mustard or sweet chili
Buffalo Chicken Salad photo

Buffalo Chicken Salad

$17.00
Mixed greens, grilled chicken with mild sauce, bacon, tomato, bleu cheese crumbles, cheddar and avocado, served with garlic bread and your choice of dressing
Grilled Shrimp photo

Grilled Shrimp

$17.00
Mixed greens, grilled shrimp, pineapple salsa, pickled onion, diced tomato, cabbage, carrots and spicy Asian dressing, topped with won-tons
Taco Salad photo

Taco Salad

$14.00
Tortilla shell filled with romaine, taco meat, tomato, green onion, black olive and cheddar. Served with sour cream and salsa, or avocado poblano ranch | Sub Verde Chicken Pork Carnitas $2.00 | Add Avocados $2.00 | Add Guacamole $3.00 | Add Jalapeños $1.50
Auntie Tal's photo

Auntie Tal's

$17.00
Mixed greens, grilled chicken, bacon, feta, dried cranberries, topped with Granny Smith apples and candied pecans, served with honey mustard and garlic bread
Grilled Chicken Caesar photo

Grilled Chicken Caesar

$14.00
Romaine, house-made croutons, and grilled chicken in a creamy Caesar dressing, served with garlic bread. Sub Shrimp $2.00

Burgers

Sides: Your choice of Tally Fries, Chips, Cup of Homemade Soup, Coleslaw, Veggie Sticks with Dill Dip. Sub Sour Cream Tally Chips .50 | Chili .50 | Garlic Parmesan Tally Fries $2 | Beer Cheese Tally Fries with Bacon $4 | Side Salad $3 | Side Caesar Salad $4.00 | Sub Grilled Chicken, or Crispy Chicken | Sub Impossible Burger $1

Queso Blanco photo

Queso Blanco

$16.00
Topped with pepper jack cheese, cheese sauce, Pico de Gallo, jalapeño and avocado
Deluxe photo

Deluxe

$16.00
Served on a pretzel bun with your choice of cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and onion
Aloha Burger photo

Aloha Burger

$17.00
Served on a King’s Hawaiian bun, cheddar cheese, grilled pineapple, guacamole and shredded lettuce
BBQ-Bacon Jalapeño photo

BBQ-Bacon Jalapeño

$16.00
Memphis Sweet BBQ Sauce, bacon, jalapeno and pepper jack
Tallinger 1lb photo

Tallinger 1lb

$19.00
Topped with American, served with a mound of our famous haystack onion rings as your side

Tallinger 1/2lb

$14.00
Topped with American, served with a mound of our famous haystack onion rings as your side
Loaded Mushroom Swiss photo

Loaded Mushroom Swiss

$17.00
Topped with Swiss, bacon, grilled portabella mushrooms and garlic mayo
Wisco photo

Wisco

$16.00
Topped with American, Swiss, cheddar and bacon, served on a parmesan grilled Texas toast

Build Your Own

$8.00
Add protein, toppings, and sauce for an additional charge!

Build Your Own-Buns

$1.50
Kings Hawaiian Bun | Pretzel Bun

Build Your Own-Bread

$1.00
Brioche Bun | Toasted Texas Toast | Grilled Texas Toast | Parmesan Crusted Texas Toast | Marble Rye

Build Your Own-Protein

$3.00/+
1/2# Burger Patty- $5 | Prime Rib- $5 | Pork Carnitas - $4 | Grilled Chicken- $4 | Crispy Chicken- $4 | Ham - $4 | Bacon- $3 | Pepperoni - $3

Build Your Own-Cheese

First one is on us - $1 for additional slices | American | Aged Cheddar | Swiss | Pepper Jack | Provolone | Bleu Cheese Crumbles $3

Build Your Own-Toppings

$0.75/+
Lettuce .75 | Onion .75 | Pineapple Ring .75 | Pickle Chips .75 | Mushroom $1 | Tomato .75 | Jalapeño $1.5 | Avocado $2.00 | Portabella Mushroom $2 | Guacamole $3.00

Build Your Own-Sauce

$1.50
Jalapeño Cilantro | Mayo | Garlic Mayo

Wraps

Sides: Your choice of Tally Fries, Chips, Cup of Homemade Soup, Coleslaw, Veggie Sticks with Dill Dip. Sub Sour Cream Tally Chips .50 | Chili .50 | Garlic Parmesan Tally Fries $2 | Beer Cheese Tally Fries with Bacon $4 | Side Salad $3 | Side Caesar Salad $4.00

Ban Mi Portabella Wrap photo

Ban Mi Portabella Wrap

$16.00
Asian marinated grilled portabellas, red pepper, jalapeños, mixed greens, cilantro and jalapeño cilantro sauce
Chicken Caesar Wrap photo

Chicken Caesar Wrap

$15.00
Grilled or crispy chicken, romaine, parmesan cheese and caesar dressing
Fajita photo

Fajita

$16.00
Grilled chicken, green and red peppers, onion sauteed with fajita seasoning, lettuce, tomato, feta cheese and jalapeno cilantro sauce
Jerk Chicken Wrap photo

Jerk Chicken Wrap

$15.00
Grilled chicken, pineapple salsa, cabbage, provolone and Jamaican Jerk sauce
Chicken Wrap photo

Chicken Wrap

$16.00
Grilled or crispy chicken, cheddar, bacon, romaine, tomato, and your choice of any Tally’s wing sauce

Sandwiches

Sides: Your choice of Tally Fries, Chips, Cup of Homemade Soup, Coleslaw, Veggie Sticks with Dill Dip. Sub Sour Cream Tally Chips .50 | Chili .50 | Garlic Parmesan Tally Fries $2 | Beer Cheese Tally Fries with Bacon $4 | Side Salad $3 | Side Caesar Salad $4.00

Prime Rib photo

Prime Rib

$17.00
Shaved prime rib, sautéed onions and mushrooms, served on French bread with horsey sauce and a side of au jus
Tally's Signature Chicken photo

Tally's Signature Chicken

$16.00
All of your favorite things! Grilled chicken, Swiss, bacon, lettuce, tomato, raw onion and Signature Sauce, served on a brioche bun
King’s Hawaiian Hot Ham photo

King’s Hawaiian Hot Ham

$15.00
Hawaiian bun, hot ham, lettuce, tomato, mayo and your choice of cheese
Reuben photo

Reuben

$15.00
Corned beef served on grilled marble rye with Swiss, sauerkraut and a side of thousand island
Not So Nashville 2.0 photo

Not So Nashville 2.0

$16.00
Crispy chicken tossed in hot honey sauce, cheddar cheese, fried onions and pickles served on a King’s Hawaiian bun
Italian Beef photo

Italian Beef

$16.00
Homemade here at Tally’s and topped with provolone, served on French bread, with a side of au jus
Roast Beef Unwich photo

Roast Beef Unwich

$16.00
Red bell pepper filled with everything bagel seasoned cream cheese, roast beef, lettuce, tomato, chedder and avocado
Philly Cheesesteak photo

Philly Cheesesteak

$16.00
Thinly sliced prime rib, provolone cheese, grilled onion and green pepper, topped with garlic mayo, served on a French bread | Add marinara $1.50
Cuban photo

Cuban

$15.00
Pulled pork, ham, Swiss, pickles, and brown mustard, served on a French bread
Al Capone photo

Al Capone

$16.00
This Italian specialty patty made by our neighbors has a serious reputation. It comes topped with sautéed onions, green and red peppers on a garlic brioche bun, served with a side of
Bruschetta Chicken photo

Bruschetta Chicken

$16.00
Grilled chicken smothered with provolone, topped with bruschetta, parmesan and balsamic glaze, served on a toasted French roll and your choice of side

Baskets

Chicken Tenders photo

Chicken Tenders

$12.00
All-white meat tenders served with Tally fries, coleslaw and your favorite dipping sauce
Beer Battered Shrimp photo

Beer Battered Shrimp

$16.00
Lightly beer battered shrimp, Tally fries and coleslaw served with lemon and cocktail sauce

Kids 12 & Under Only

Sides: Choice of Fries or Apple Sauce

Corn Dogs photo

Corn Dogs

$8.00
Crispy mini corn dogs
Chicken Tenders photo

Chicken Tenders

$9.00
Three all white-meat tenders served with your favorite dipping sauce
1/2 Grilled Cheese photo

1/2 Grilled Cheese

$6.00
One half grilled chese

Kids Fish

$8.00
One piece of beer battered cod

Desserts

Giant Hot Chocolate Chip Cookie photo

Giant Hot Chocolate Chip Cookie

$13.00
Topped with chocolate sauce and whipped cream

Tuesday

Monday

Premium Tap Beers

$4.50

Wednesday

Homemade Dinner Night

HOMEMADE DINNER | Starting at 5pm - Dinner the Way Mom Makes It!

Domestic Bottles

$3.25

House Wine Splits

$4.50
Sutter Home

2oz Bourbon Pour

$5 OFF

Thursday

Wings photo

Wings

$1.25/+
BONELESS WINGS | Dine In $1.25 | To-Go $1.35 | TRADITIONAL | Dine-In price $1.50 To-Go price $1.60

Tall Boys

$3.00

Fireball Shots

$2.00

Friday

Beer Battered Cod

$17.00
Hand battered cod cooked to golden brown, served with tartar sauce and lemon. Your choice of fries, baked potato or potato pancakes and clam chowder, house salad or coleslaw & dinner roll

Beer Battered Perch

$20.00
Beer battered lake perch cooked to golden brown, served with tartar sauce and lemon. Your choice of fries, baked potato or potato pancakes and clam chowder, house salad or coleslaw & dinner roll

Tropical Fish Taco

$20.00
Served after 3PM | Three flour tortillas filled with flakey baked cod, pineapple salsa and cabbage, topped with chipotle sour cream, served with choice of fries, baked potato or potato pancakes and clam chowder, house salad or coleslaw & dinner roll

Baked Fish

$20.00
Served after 3PM | Cod prepared in a butter sauce served with tartar sauce, lemon and drawn butter Your choice of fries, baked potato or potato pancakes and clam chowder, house salad or coleslaw & dinner roll

Fish Fry & Specials

Step 1: Clam Chowder • Salad • Coleslaw | Step 2: Tally Fries • Baked Potato • Potato Pancakes | Served with a dinner roll

Kids Fish

$8.00
One piece of beer battered cod, served with lemon and tartar and your choice of fries or applesauce

Domestic Taps

$3.00/+

Tall Double Titos | Tall Double Captain Morgan

$5.00

Carbliss

$5.00

Saturday

Karaoke 9:30-1:00

Supreme Nachos photo

Supreme Nachos

$14.00/Full Size
Tortilla chips piled with cheese, beef, tomato, black olive and green onion, served with sour cream and salsa

Tequila-30 All Day

Tequila Drinks | Tequila Shots $1.00 OFF

Drink Specials

$4.00/+
Tall Double Rail Mixers $6.00 | White Claws $4.00

Sunday Funday

Pitcher & Pretzel photo

Pitcher & Pretzel

$1.00/+
FREE domestic pitcher with any pretzel purchase for dine-in only | Valid for 21 or older

Craft Cans

$1.00 OFF
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs